Last updated on Nov. 23, 2021. Compiled by James Hirsh and Gabe Pulver. For more Jewish sports discussion and trivia, subscribe to the Menschwarmers podcast.
| MLB | NFL | NHL | NBA |
| Hank Greenberg (1935 AL MVP, 1940 AL MVP) | Sid Luckman (1943 Joe F. Carr Trophy [MVP]) | Jason Zucker (2019 King Clancy Memorial Trophy) | Dolph Schayes (1949 NBL Rookie of the Year) |
| Lou Boudreau (1948 AL MVP) | Andre Tippett (1985 Defensive Player of the Year) | Adam Fox (2021 Norris Memorial Trophy) | Red Auerbach (1965 NBA Coach of the Year, 1980 NBA Executive of the Year) |
| Al Rosen (1953 AL MVP) | Julian Edelman (2019 Super Bowl MVP) | Jerry Krause (1988, 1996 NBA Executive of the Year) | |
| Larry Sherry (1959 World Series MVP) | Larry Brown (2001 Coach of the Year) | ||
| Sandy Koufax (1963 NL Cy Young, 1963 NL MVP, 1965 NL Cy Young, 1966 NL Cy Young) | Amar’e Stoudemire (2003 NBA Rookie of the Year) | ||
| Steve Stone (1980 AL Cy Young) | Lawrence Frank (2020 NBA Executive of the Year) | ||
| Steve Yeager (1981 World Series MVP) | |||
| Ryan Braun (2007 AL Rookie of the Year, 2011 NL MVP) | | ||
| Bob Melvin (2007 NL Manager of the Year, 2012 AL MOY, 2018 AL MOY) | |||
| Gabe Kapler (2021 NL Manager of the Year) |